In the insurance industry, especially in markets like Hong Kong and the U.S., two practices often spark debate: rebating and the involvement of unlicensed third parties. Rebating happens when brokers or agents offer customers a portion of the premium or commission as an incentive to buy insurance. Meanwhile, unlicensed third parties are people without proper licenses who still dabble in regulated activities, like advising on policies or handling sales. These practices are frequently intertwined—particularly when brokers use a customer’s friends or relatives as go-betweens to pass along rebates. But are they legal? And do they really help customers more than good advice? Let’s break it down step by step, exploring what these practices mean, how they play out in the real world, and what the rules say about them.

---

What Is Rebating, and Is It Legal?

Rebating is essentially giving customers a financial perk—like returning part of the premium or commission—after they buy insurance. It’s a bit like getting cash back on a purchase, but in insurance, the rules around it are strict.

• The Above-Board Way:
  Rebating can be legal if it’s done openly and documented. For instance, an insurer might say, “Sign up now and get 10% off your premium!” That’s a discount, and it’s fine as long as it’s written into the policy or quote. Or they might offer, “Pay now, and we’ll refund 5% later”—that’s a rebate, also okay if it’s clearly stated in the paperwork. Transparency is key: You know what you’re getting, and there’s no funny business hiding a bad deal.
• The Shady Way:
  Trouble starts when rebates go off the books. Picture a broker saying, “Buy this policy, and I’ll quietly give you $50 later.” That’s an undocumented rebate, and it’s illegal in many places. This often happens with long-term insurance—like life insurance—where customers might be swayed by cash or gifts without realizing the policy isn’t right for them. It’s like being bribed to pick a lousy phone plan just because you get a kickback.

In Hong Kong, the Insurance Authority’s Guideline on Offering of Gifts (GL25) bans undocumented rebates for long-term insurance products. In the U.S., many states follow the National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC) Model Laws, which also crack down on sneaky rebates. So, rebating isn’t always illegal—but it has to be out in the open, not under the table.

---

What’s the Deal with Unlicensed Third Parties?

Unlicensed third parties are people who aren’t licensed to sell insurance but still get involved in things like giving advice or managing transactions. This is where the waters get muddy.

• How It Works:
  Some brokers use unlicensed referrers—think middlemen—to drum up business, often targeting groups like visitors from Mainland China in Hong Kong. These referrers don’t just connect people to brokers; they sell policies—explaining options, recommending plans, and even handling paperwork. That’s a problem because, legally, only licensed intermediaries can do those things. In Hong Kong, the Insurance Ordinance (Cap. 41), Section 64G makes this crystal clear: No license, no selling. Breaking this rule can lead to fines up to HK$1,000,000 and two years in prison.
• Why It’s Risky:
  Imagine hiring an unlicensed electrician—wires crossed, sparks fly, and you’re in trouble. Unlicensed third parties are similar: They might not know the rules or might push lousy policies to make a quick buck. The Insurance Authority Circular (22 May 2024) warns that this puts customers at risk of scams or bad deals, threatening the market’s integrity.

---

How Do Friends and Relatives Fit In?

One sneaky tactic ties rebating and unlicensed third parties together: using a customer’s friends or relatives as introducers.

• The Playbook:
  Say your friend tells you about an awesome insurance deal. They’re not licensed, but they explain the policy, convince you it’s perfect, and maybe even help you sign up. After you buy, the broker pays your friend a cut of the commission, and your friend slips some of that cash back to you as a “favor.” It’s a rebate in disguise, channeled through someone you trust.
• The Catch:
  This is usually illegal. Your friend isn’t licensed, so they shouldn’t be advising you or handling the sale—that’s regulated work. Plus, that “favor” is likely an undocumented rebate, breaking rules like Hong Kong’s GL25 or U.S. anti-rebating laws. It’s a common trick—some say it’s standard in certain markets—but common doesn’t mean legal.

---

So, Is This Allowed?

Short answer: No, it’s usually not. Here’s the breakdown:

• Unlicensed Introducers:
  If your friend just says, “Check out this broker,” that’s fine. But if they’re explaining policies or pushing you to buy, they’re doing regulated activities without a license—illegal. Hong Kong’s Insurance Ordinance and similar laws elsewhere don’t mess around with this.
• Undocumented Rebates:
  If the broker funnels money through your friend and you get a cut, that’s an undocumented rebate—not in the policy, not legal. The Insurance Authority Circular (22 May 2024) calls out these “non-compliant business models,” warning they can lead to mis-selling and hefty penalties.

Even if everyone’s doing it, regulators are watching, and the consequences can be brutal.

---

Rebates vs. Advice: What’s Better for Customers?

Now, let’s wrestle with a big question: Do rebates help customers more than professional advice? Let’s play devil’s advocate.

The Case for Rebates

• Cash Now:
  A rebate is immediate—$100 in your pocket today beats vague promises of future savings. It’s tangible, and people like that.
• Skepticism of Advice:
  Some brokers push products that pad their own wallets, not yours. If you don’t trust the advice, a rebate feels like a safer bet—at least you’re getting something upfront.

The Case for Advice

• Bigger Payoff Later:
  Good advice can save you thousands over time by picking the right policy—way more than a one-time rebate. It’s about long-term value, not a quick hit.
• Avoiding Traps:
  Rebates can lure you into bad policies. The Insurance Authority warns that this often leads to mis-selling—buying coverage that doesn’t fit. Advice helps you dodge that bullet.

The Takeaway:
Rebates are a shiny lure, but advice is the net that keeps you safe. Short-term gains can’t match long-term smarts.

---

Set Up a Broker to Learn the Market?

Curious about the insurance world? You might wonder, “Should I start my own brokerage to figure it out?” It’s a bold move—let’s weigh it.

Why It Could Work

• Deep Dive:
  Running a brokerage teaches you the nuts and bolts—products, commissions, rules—better than any book. You’d live the market, not just study it.
• Insider View:
  You’d connect with insurers and see how deals really happen, giving you a front-row seat.

Why It’s Tough

• Cost and Risk:
  It’s pricey—staff, systems, licenses—and risky. Break a rule, and you’re facing fines or shutdown. The Insurance Authority doesn’t play nice with rookies who slip up.
• Time Sink:
  Getting licensed and learning the ropes takes years. That’s a lot just to “learn.”

Smarter Move:
Try shadowing a licensed broker or hitting industry seminars. You’ll learn plenty without betting the farm.

---

Wrapping It Up

Rebating and unlicensed third parties might be widespread, but they’re often on the wrong side of the law. Here’s the gist:

• Rebates Need Paperwork:
  If it’s not in the policy, it’s illegal. No exceptions.
• Unlicensed Means Hands Off:
  Friends can point you to a broker, but they can’t sell or advise—only licensed pros can.
• Advice Trumps Rebates:
  Cash today is nice, but smart advice saves more tomorrow.

Whether you’re buying insurance or thinking of jumping into the industry, keep it clean. Rules matter, and shortcuts like rebates through unlicensed pals can backfire. The market respects knowledge and honesty—stick to that, and you’ll come out ahead.